Colleges under Delhi University are asking astronomical grades for journalism courses. Does scoring high grades in school make someone a good journalist?
My friend George Holland -Hill served as a sub –editor for
almost all the major UK national newspapers. He once told me that he had to hide
the fact that he had a degree in English while hunting for a job in the
newspaper industry.
"I always kept low- profile, careful enough not to let
anyone know that I had a degree. No one really cared about a degree, because in
those days no one had one,” said George.
He said: “ If you walked up to someone in the Fleet Street in 1970s and said I have a degree and want a journalism job, people would frown at you.
They would rather hire someone who had some sort of practical experience like
working for the village newspaper.”
He narrated an incident about a bloke on a look out for a reporter's job in Manchester. It was a Christmas day and a young lad died in
an accident because of excessive drinking. The editor asked the young boy who
was looking for a job, if he could go out early in the morning, knock at the family’s
door, who lost their son on the pervious day and request them for their son’s
photograph. That was a real test!
Journalism is not
about learning theory. It is about deploying real –life skills and acquiring practical knowledge
either at work, through internship or doing a short-term professional course.
But, at the end, journalism is all about passion.
I find it extremely strange, when I read in newspapers that
one needs above 95% to study journalism in Delhi University. I wondered if
anyone has to be that intelligent to study journalism. Moreover, does one really
need three years and then an additional postgraduate degree (five years in
total) to be a journalist?
A person who wants to be a journalist must have a strong
nose for news. He (or She) must love cultures and be adventurous. The person must be an inborn
leader, possess strong management skills and be able to work in a team. It is also important to be a strong negotiator, a great listener and a very good salesman. Above
all, the person has to be a very tolerant and liberal.
These are the inherent skills of a journalist, other than
acquiring and perfecting the practical skills like ability to write well, and
in case of a television and radio journalist ability to speak and edit well.
Whilst the find product of a journalist reveals the person’s
great writing and speaking skills, the inherent qualities mentioned above are
mostly required at the production stage. For example, it requires a great
craftsmanship to convince someone to give an interview. Remember in journalism, you are asking someone’s time without giving something in return.
I discovered my talent in journalism while writing a letter
to the editor following 9/11. I then realized that I am more inclined towards
international affairs- something that couldn’t have occurred to me when I was
at school.
School level grades are not enough to access someone’s
journalist abilities. The maturity to understand social and global issues at
large comes with time, and not on someone’s ability to score high grades at
school leaving exams. The decision of some colleges of Delhi University to
scrap entrance exams for the journalism course in not a prudent step, and it
spells disaster for the next generation of Indian journalists, as they are
likely be too driven by the market and not by passion.
This is a scenario of elimination & not selection !
ReplyDelete